Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (2024)

Holiday Cookie Recipes

Tis’ the season for cookie recipes.
Bring something special to your holiday gatherings this year!
This list has a holiday cookie recipe for everyone.

Halloween has officially passed us by, so you know what that means… It is basically Christmas.
Everyone knows that seasons are no longer dictated by mere dates.
The holiday season starts when Starbucks releases their festive cup prints! (And guess what I am holding on to as I type this now… 😉 )

The holiday season means cooler weather, visiting family, gatherings and parties, and of course- desserts.
One of the most famous holiday desserts may just be the cookie.
Cookies have been a go-to holiday dessert for decades.

The Holiday Cookie

Holiday cookies come in all shapes, sizes, flavors, and textures.
They are widely appreciated for several reasons:
1. They transport well.
2. Many holiday cookie recipes utilize the simple ingredients you already have in your pantry.
3. They are easy to make and to eat!

Not to mention cookies are delicious.
I am pretty sure that is a requirement for something to be counted as a cookie.
It absolutely has to taste good.

In this list of my 20 favorite Holiday Cookie Recipes, you will find the perfect cookie for just about anyone!

The List

In this list of Holiday Cookie Recipes, you will find cookies for all tastes and skill levels.
From decently involved processes to just assembly required recipes, your holiday cookie needs will most definitely be met.

Because these recipes are all amazing (of course they are, if they weren’t I wouldn’t be sharing them with you) they are listed in no particular order.

Speaking of the holidays, do you have an infant to shop for this season? Check out my Infant Gift Guide to find the best baby gifts of 2018!

Hot Chocolate Cookies

Nothing says winter weather quite like a delightful cup of hot cocoa.
These chewy cookies bring it to a whole new level.
Averie from Averie Cooks has embodied hot chocolate within a cookie, marshmallow and all.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (1)

Image Credit to Averie Cooks

Get theHot Chocolate Cookies Recipe HERE!

Stained Glass Sugar Cookies

These sugar cookies are simple to make with a gorgeous (and tasty!) result.
Sara at Dinner At The Zoo has created these beauties.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (2)

Image Credit to Dinner At The Zoo

Get the Stained Glass Sugar Cookie Recipe HERE!
There is even a video!

Soft and Chewy Gingerbread Men

My husband, Andrew, and I love to watch cooking shows.
Especially British ones.
But, the cookie (biscuit) rounds make my husband cringe.
Andrew is a firm believer that cookies should be soft and chewy 99.9% of the time.

So, these gingerbread cookies are for him and seriously for everyone else.
If you are a crisp gingerbread person, not to fear!
Michelle at Brown Eyed Baker has the recipe for those too.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (3)

Image Credit to Brown Eyed Baker

Get this Soft and Chewy Gingerbread Recipe HERE!
You will find the crispy version there as well.

Peppermint Patties

Peppermint flavor is a holiday favorite.
But you can do so much more than serve a bowl of candy canes!
These homemade peppermint patties are brought to us by Mel at Mel’s Kitchen Cafe.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (4)

Image Credit to Mel’s Kitchen Cafe

Get the Peppermint Patty Recipe HERE!

Melted Snowman Oreo Truffles

Are truffles cookies?
Well, they do fit my above criteria…
And ya know what, these melting snowmen are far too adorable not to count as a cookie.
Oreo truffles are officially cookies.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (5)

Image Credit to A Pumpkin and A Princess

Check out Crystal’s Melting Snowman Oreo Truffle recipe HERE to recreate these charming little guys.

Spiral Sugar Cookies

Add some color to your cookie tray this season with these sugar cookies!
Megan at Pip and Debby is responsible for these vibrant treats.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (6)

Image Credit to Pip and Debby

Get the Spiral Sugar Cookie Recipe HERE!

Pecan Pie Cookies

Holly from Spend With Pennies is in my top favorite people now.
I LOVE pecans.
Why it never occured to me to turn Pecan Pie into a cookie is beyond me.

Luckily, Holly is wiser than I when it comes to cookie transformations.
She was then kind enough to share her wisdom with the rest of the world.
So, here they are.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (7)

Image Credit to Spend With Pennies

Doesn’t that look amazing?!
Let me tell you, it is.
Find the recipe for Pecan Pie Cookies HERE!

Christmas Tree Meringue Cookies

My mom loves meringue.
Between the two of us, we could probably polish off a few batches of meringue cookies by ourselves.
As far as Holiday Cookie Recipes go, these meringues are a more unique and scrumptious option!

Mira at Cooking LSL made these Christmas Tree Meringue Cookies.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (8)

Image Credit to Cooking LSL

Ana Tip- add a little bit of green food coloring to the meringue and then sprinkle with sparkling sugar to give a lightly dusted Christmas Tree look.

To get this Christmas Tree Meringue Cookie recipe check Mira out HERE!

Soft-Baked White Chocolate Chip Cranberry Cookies

Sally at Sally’s Baking Addiction makes some fantastic flavor combinations.
These White Chocolate Chip Cranberry cookies are no exception!

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (9)

Image Credit to Sally’s Baking Addiction

The recipe for these White Chocolate Chip Cranberry Cookies is found HERE!

Cream Cheese Spritz Cookies

Spritz cookies are a Christmas classic.
Sara at Dinner at the Zoo proves that classic does not have to be boring!

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (10)

Image Credit to Dinner at The Zoo

The Cream Cheese Spritz Cookie recipe can be found HERE!

Butterscotch Brown Sugar Cashew Cookies

Cashews are so underused when baking!
These cookies by Denise at Sweetpea and Saffron are perfect for the salty/sweet lovers out there.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (11)

Image Credit to Sweetpea and Saffron

Find the recipe HERE for these Butterscotch Brown Sugar Cashew Cookies!

Paleo/Vegan/Gluten Free Gingersnap Cookies with Apple and Caramel

I know what you may be thinking, but it is 2018!
The words “vegan” “gluten free” and even “paleo” can now pair with the phrase “delicious dessert”!
You have to try Taylor’s gingersnaps from Food Faith Fitness!
They are just about too good to be true… almost 😉

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (12)

Image Credit to Food Faith Fitness!

Get the full recipe for these Healthy Gingersnap Cookies HERE!

Coconut Macaroons

Coconut macaroons are amazing!
I really love any holiday cookie recipe that involves simply scooping the dough onto a baking sheet.

These chewy macaroons were crafted by Sally at Sally’s Baking Addiction.
Not only has she provided us with a lovely coconut macaroon, but she has included FOUR versions of this versatile cookie!
Each of them perfect for your next holiday bash.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (13)

Image Credit toSally’s Baking Addiction

The recipe for theseCoconut Macaroons (and their 4 varieties) can be found HERE.

Chocolate Kiss Powder Puff Cookies (Snowballs!)

What is better for a winter cookie than a cookie that looks like a snowball?!
I live in Iowa- we get a lot of snow and I am still excited about these.
I can’t even imagine how excited I would be if I lived in a place that seldom got snow!

These sneaky Powder Puff Cookies with a secret Chocolate Kiss inside are created by Averie of Averie Cooks.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (14)

Image Credit to Averie Cooks.

The Chocolate Kiss Powder Puff Cookie recipe is found HERE!

Eggnog Cookies With Rum Sugar Glaze

If a holiday cookie can be elegant- it would be these eggnog cookies.
These cookies by Olivia at Liv for Cake are gorgeous, sophisticated, and taste heavenly.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (15)

Image Credit to Liv for Cake.

Find her recipe for these Eggnog Cookies HERE!

Nutter Butter Snowmen

If you cannot already tell, I kinda think snowmen rock.
These Nutter Butter Snowmen are great for the homemakers out there who don’t love to bake.
Or for those who simply appreciate a good nutter butter.

These snowmen are designed by Michelle at Brown Eyed Baker.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (16)

Image Credit to Brown Eyed Baker.

Get the instructions to make these Nutter Butter Snowmen Here!

Christmas Wreath Cookies

These cookies practically scream Christmas.
What’s even better is that they are no bake and only take about 15 minutes to make!
Crazy right?!

Sara with Dinner at the Zoo brings her creativity forward again with this holiday cookie recipe.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (17)

Image Credit to Dinner at the Zoo.

Get the recipe for these Christmas Wreath Cookies HERE!

Peppermint Whoopie Pies

I have recently discovered that some people have never heard of whoopie pies…
Those people are seriously missing out.
And, these Peppermint Whoopie Pies by Michelle of Brown Eyed Baker pair nicely with what? A Starbucks Peppermint Mocha of course!

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (18)

Image Credit toBrown Eyed Baker.

The recipe for these Peppermint Whoopie Pies can be found HERE!

Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies

Thumbprint cookies were a family holiday staple growing up.
Holly at Spend With Pennies has wonderfully brought back those nostalgic feelings with her Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (19)

Image Credit to Spend With Pennies.

Get this Raspberry Thumbprint Cookie recipe HERE!

Salted Caramel Cinnamon Macarons

Last and certainly not least we have these Salted Caramel Cinnamon Macarons from Sally’s Baking Addiction.
Do not let macaron’s scare you, the look Pinterest perfect, but they are definitely not only for the pros!
These French inspired cookies are perfect for a holiday bash or a Netflix binge party of one.

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (20)

Image Credit to Sally’s Baking Addiction.

Get Sally’s recipe for her Salted Caramel Cinnamon Macarons HERE!

The Holidays are a great time to break out the best of the best cookie recipes. I hope this list has helped you and inspired you to get the most of your homemaking life!

Head over HERE to get access to My Homemaking Resource Library! In the library, you will find helpful printables including a meal planner and a grocery list to optimize shopping. I look forward to seeing you there!

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (21)

Holiday Cookie Recipes- A Cookie for Every Taste - My Homemaking Life (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Jamar Nader

Last Updated:

Views: 5810

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (75 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jamar Nader

Birthday: 1995-02-28

Address: Apt. 536 6162 Reichel Greens, Port Zackaryside, CT 22682-9804

Phone: +9958384818317

Job: IT Representative

Hobby: Scrapbooking, Hiking, Hunting, Kite flying, Blacksmithing, Video gaming, Foraging

Introduction: My name is Jamar Nader, I am a fine, shiny, colorful, bright, nice, perfect, curious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.